Old Mill Gumbo Spicy combinations of vegetables, whole Blue Crab Claws, shrimp and shredded crab meat served with white rice. Old Mill Salad or Caesar Salad Classic Old Mill Salad. West Indies Seafood Salad A blend of Seafood, green peppers, celery, green onions, and homemade Italian dressing. Served on a bed of lettuce. (Lunch Portion is ...